La Silenciosa Expansión de la Jurisdicción Internacional
Keywords:
universal jurisdiction, international criminal law, international crimes, transnational prosecutionsAbstract
Based on an original worldwide survey of all universal jurisdiction complaints over core international crimes presented between 1961 and 2017 and against widespread perception by international criminal law experts that universal jurisdiction is in decline, this article shows that universal jurisdiction practice has been quietly expanding as there has been a significant growth in the number of universal jurisdiction trials, in the frequency with which these trials take place year by year and in the geographical scope of universal jurisdiction litigation. This expansion is likely the result of, among other factors, the adoption of International Criminal Court implementing statutes, the creation of specialized international crimes units by states, institutional learning by states and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), technological changes, new migration and refugee waves to universal jurisdiction states, criticisms of inter- national criminal law as neo-colonial and the search of new venues by human rights NGOs. The expansion of universal jurisdiction has been quiet because most tried defendants have been low-level, universal jurisdiction states have not made an effort to publicize these trials and observers have wrongly assumed that Belgium and Spain were representative of universal jurisdiction trends. The article finally assesses positive and negative aspects of the quiet expansion of universal jurisdiction for its defenders and critics.
Downloads
References
African Rights & Redress, Survivors and post-genocide justice in Rwanda: their experiences, perspectives, and hopes, 2008, Londres.
ALIBI, “The Slow Death of Universal Jurisdiction: The Case of Spain”, 10/10/2014.
Amnesty International, “Denmark/Iraq: International Justice for the victims of Halabja”, 22/11/2002, EUR 18/002/2002, URL https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/116000/eur180022002en.pdf consultado 03/04/2021.
Audiencia Nacional De España, Sala de lo penal, Sección 3ª, “Caso Scilingo”, 19/04/2005.
——, Sala de lo Penal, Sección N° 2, Extradición 45/2013, Auto N° 14/2014, 30/04/2014.
——, Sala de lo Penal, Sección N° 3, Rollo de Sala 62/13, Procedimiento de Origen: Extradición 21/13, Auto N° 14, 24/04/2014.
BASS, Gary J., Freedom's battle: the origins of humanitarian intervention, Vintage, 2009, Nueva York.
BEN-ARI, Rephael, “Universal Jurisdiction: Chronicle of a Death Foretold?”, en Denver Journal of International Law & Policy, 2014-2015, Issue 43, Nº 2, 04/2015, pp. 165-198.
BOLHUIS, Maarten & BATTJEZ, Hemme & VAN WIJK, Joris, “Undesirable but Unreturnable Migrants in the Netherlands”, en Refugee Survey Quarterly, 2017, 36, Nº 1, 03/2017, pp. 61-84 URL https://doi.org/10.1093/rsq/hdw019, consultado el 03/04/2021.
BRODY, Reed, Victims bring a dictator to Justice: the case of Hissène Habré, Germany Bread for the World - Protestant Development Service Protestant Agency for Diakonie and Development, 2017, Berlín.
CÁCERES, María Stella, 60 años de impunidad - Paraguay: Los crímenes del stronismo en el ámbito de la justicia universal, Fundación Celestina Pérez de Almada, 2014, Asunción.
Cámara Federal de Casación Penal, Sala 4, “Salmerón, Rubén Amor Benedicto s/recurso de casación”, Expte. Nº CFP 4591/2010/7/CFC2, 11/06/2018.
Cámara Nacional de Apelaciones en lo Criminal y Correccional Federal, Sala II, “NN s/ desestimación de denuncia y archivo”, 03/09/2010.
CANTOR, David J. & VAN WIJK, Joris & SINGER, Sarah y otros/as, Undesirable and Unreturnable Migrants: Policy challenges around excluded asylum seekers and other migrants suspected of serious criminality who cannot be removed, Centro de Justicia Penal Internacional, 2016 URL https://cicj.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Undesirable-and-Unreturnable-Full-report.pdf consultado el 03/04/2021.
Chambre Africaine Extraordinaire d’Assises d’Appel, “Le Procureur Général c. Hissein Habré”, 27/04/2017.
Chambre Africaine Extraordinaire d’Assises, “Ministère Public c. Hissein Habré”, 30/05/2016.
CHEHTMAN, Alejandro, The Philosophical foundations of extraterritorial punishment, Oxford University Press, 2011, Oxford.
CLARKE, Kamari M., Africa and the ICC. Realities and perceptions, Cambridge University Press, 2016, Cambridge.
Clear Harmony, “Summary of European Lawsuits against Jiang Zemin and his Accomplices from the Chinese Communist Party”, 16/03/2005 URL https://www.clearharmony.net/articles/a25406-Summary-of-European-Lawsuits-against-Jiang-Zemin-and-his-Accomplices-from-the-Chinese-Communist-Party.html#.YGmP0uhKjIU consultado 03/04/2021.
Constitutional Court of South Africa, “National Commissioner of The South African Police Service v. Southern African Human Rights Litigation Centre and Another”, 03/10/2014.
Contexto y Acción, “Nos cuesta horrores seguir investigando los crímenes del franquismo”, 07/08/2018 URL https://ctxt.es/es/20180801/Politica/21138/Argentina-franquismo-Maria-Servini-de-Cubria-juicio-Cesar-G-Calero.htm consultado 03/04/2021.
Convención contra la Tortura y Otros Tratos o Penas Crueles, Inhumanas o Degradantes, 10/12/1984, Nueva York, e.v. 26/06/1987.
Convención Europea de Derechos Humanos, 04/11/1950, Roma, e.v. 03/09/1953.
Corte Internacional de Justicia, “Case Concerning the Arrest Warrant of 11 April 2000”, “Democratic Republic of the Congo v Belgium”, 14/02/2002, I.C.J. Reports 3.
——, “Caso Hissène Habré”, “Questions Relating to the Obligation to Prosecute or Extradite”, “Bélgica c. Senegal”, 20/07/2012.
Corte Penal Internacional, Sala de Cuestiones Preliminares II, “El Fiscal c. al Bashir”, 06/07/2017.
Council of the European Union, African Union-European Union Technical ad-hoc Expert Group, 8672/1/09REV1, Report on the Principle of Universal Jurisdiction, 15/04/2009.
DE LA RASILLA DEL MORAL, Ignacio, “The Swan Song of universal Jurisdiction in Spain”, en International Criminal Law Review, 2009, 9, Nº5, 01/2009, pp. 777-808.
Deutsche Welle, “Refugees in Germany reporting dozens of war crimes”, 11/04/2016, URL https://www.dw.com/en/refugees-in-germany-reporting-dozens-of-war-crimes/a-19179291 consultado 03/04/2021.
DOĞAR, Didem, “Against All Odds: Turkey’s Response to ‘Undesirable but Unreturnable’ Asylum-Seekers”, en Refugee Survey Quarterly, 2017, 36, Nº 1, 03/2017, pp. 107-125 URL https://doi.org/10.1093/rsq/hdw027 consultado 03/04/2021.
Dominio de Canadá, Deschênes Commmission of Inquiry on War Criminals, 1987.
DRUMBL, Mark, Atrocity, punishment, and international law, Cambridge University Press, 2007, Nueva York.
ECCHR, “Arrest Warrant against Jamil Hassan is a Milestone and Good News for All Affected by Assad’s Torture System”, 08/06/2018 URL https://www.ecchr.eu/en/press-release/arrest-warrant-against-jamil-hassan-is-a-milestone-and-good-news-for-all-affected-by-assads-torture-system/ consultado 03/04/2021.
El País, “La jueza Servini ordena otra vez detener a Martín Villa para que declare”, 18/07/2017 URL https://elpais.com/politica/2017/07/18/actualidad/1500387066_677290.html consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “La justicia argentina revoca la orden de detención a Martín Villa por los sucesos de Vitoria de 1976”, 14/07/2017 URL https://elpais.com/politica/2017/07/14/actualidad/1500036117_316975.html?rel=mas consultado 03/04/2021.
Estatuto de Roma de la Corte Penal Internacional, 17/07/1998, Roma, Italia, e.v. 10/08/2010, texto aprobado por la República Francesa Ley 2010-930.
Euronews, “Spanish archaeologists uncover mass graves with victims of Franco’s regime”, 16/06/2017 URL https://www.euronews.com/2017/06/16/spanish-archaeologists-uncover-mass-graves-with-victims-of-franco-s-regim consultado 03/04/2021.
European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights, “Survivors of Assad's torture regime demand justice - German authorities issue first international arrest warrant”, 2019 URL https://www.ecchr.eu/en/case/torture-under-the-assad-regime/ consultado 03/04/2021.
GAHIMA, Gerald, Transitional justice in Rwanda: accountability for atrocity, Routledge, 2013, Londres.
GARROD, Matthew, “Unraveling the Confused Relationship between Treaty Obligations to Extradite or Prosecute and ‘Universal Jurisdiction’ in the Light of the Habré Case”, en Harvard International Law Journal, 2018, 59, Nº 1, pp. 125-196.
GOLASH, Deirdre, “The Justification of Punishment in the International Context” en MAY, Larry & HOSKINS, Zachary, The Justification of Punishment in the International Context, Cambridge University Press, 2010.
GOLDSMITH, Jack & KRASNER, Stephen, “The Pitfalls of Idealism” en Daedalus, 2003, 132, Nº 1, pp. 47-64.
HANNICH, Rolf, “Justice in the Name of All. Die praktische Anwendung des Völkerstrafgesetzbuchs aus der Sicht des Generalbundesanwalts beim Bundesgerichtshof”, en Zeitschrift für Internationale Strafrechtsdogmatik, 2007, 13, pp. 507-514.
HASKELL, Leslie & Human Rights Watch, The long arm of justice: lessons from specialized war crimes units in France, Germany, and the Netherlands, Human Rights Watch, 2014, Nueva York.
HETHERINGTON, Thomas & CHALMERS, William, War crimes: report of the War Crimes Inquiry, The Stationery Office Books, 1989, Londres.
HOVELL, Devika, “The Authority of Universal Jurisdiction”, en European Journal of International Law, 2018, 29, Nº 2, pp. 427-456.
Human Rights Watch, “G20: Saudi Crown Prince Faces Legal Scrutiny”, 2018 URL www.hrw.org/news/2018/11/26/g20-saudi-crown-prince-faces-legal-scrutiny consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “‘These Are the Crimes We Are Fleeing’ Justice for Syria in Swedish and German Courts”, 2017.
HWANG, Eric L., “China: The Growth of a new Superpower and the Extinction of Universal Jurisdiction”, en Wisconsin International Law Journal¸ 2014, 32, Nº 2, 08/2014, pp. 334-354.
JALLOH, Charles C., “Universal Jurisdiction, Universal Prescription? A Preliminary Assessment of the African Union Perspective on Universal Jurisdiction”, en Criminal Law Forum, 2010, 21, Nº 1, pp. 1-65.
JEßBERGER, Florian, “‘On Behalf of Africa’: towards the Regionalization of Universal Jurisdiction?”, en WERLE, Gerhard, Africa and the International Criminal Court, Asser Press, 2014, Berlín.
——, “Towards a ‘complementary preparedness’ approach to universal jurisdiction - recent trends and best practices in the European Union”, en Workshop Universal jurisdiction and international crimes: constraints and best practices, Policy Department for External Relations Directorate General for External Policies of the Union, 2018.
JOHNSON, Björn & LUNDVALL, Bengt-Åke, The Learning Economy and the Economics of Hope, Anthem Press, 2016, Londres.
JOHNSON, Björn, “Institutional Learning”, en LUNDVALL, Bengt-Åke, National systems of innovation: Toward a theory of innovation and interactive learning, Anthem, 2012, Londres.
Jurist, “Sweden prosecutor brings war crimes charges aginst former Bosnian prison guard”, 05/10/2010 URL https://www.jurist.org/news/2010/10/sweden-prosecutor-brings-war-crimes-charges-against-former-bosnian-prison-guard/ consultado 03/04/2021.
Just Security, “The ICC’s New Libya Case: Extraterritorial Evidence for an Extraterritorial Court”, 23/08/2017 URL https://www.justsecurity.org/44383/iccs-libya-case-extraterritorial-evidence-extraterritorial-court/?print consultado 03/04/2021.
Juzgado Nacional Criminal y Correccional Federal N° 1, “Galván Abascal Celso; Muñecas Aguilar; Giralte Gónzalez, José Ignacio y otros s/ imposición de torturas”, 30/10/2014.
——, “NN s/genocidio”, Expte. N° CFP 4591/2010, 18/09/2013.
KALECK, Wolfgang & KROKER, Patrick, “Syrian Torture Investigations in Germany and Beyond: Breathing New Life into Universal Jurisdiction in Europe?”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2018, 16, Nº 1, 03/2018, pp. 165-191.
KECK, Margaret & SIKKINK, Kathryn, Activists beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics, Cornell University Press, 1998, Ithaca.
KISSINGER, Henry Alfred, “The Pitfalls of Universal Jurisdiction”, en Foreign Affairs, 2001, 80, Nº 4, 07/2001, pp. 86-96.
KOENIG, Alexa, “Harnessing Social Media as Evidence of Grave International Crimes”, en Human Rights Center, UC Berkeley School of Law, 2017 URL https://medium.com/humanrightscenter/harnessing-social-media-as-evidence-of-grave-international-crimes-d7f3e86240d consultado 03/04/2021.
KONTOROVICH, Eugene, “The Inefficiency of Universal Jurisdiction”, en University of Illinois Law Review, 2008, U. Ill. L. Rev. 389, 12/2007, pp. 389-418.
La Nación, “La justicia argentina define una denuncia contra el príncipe saudita”, 27/11/2018 URL https://www.lanacion.com.ar/politica/la-justicia-argentina-define-una-denuncia-contra-el-principe-saudita-nid2196874/ consultado 03/04/2021.
La Nación, “Piden informes al exterior del príncipe saudita, pero no quedará detenido”, 28/11/2018 URL https://www.lanacion.com.ar/politica/desestiman-detencion-del-principe-saudita-piden-informes-nid2197143/ consultado 03/04/2021.
LANGER, Máximo, “Das Völkerstrafgesetzbuch und die Prinzipien der Beteiligung und Rechenschaft gegenüber der internationalen Gemeinschaft”, en Zehn Jahre Völkerstrafgesetzbuch, 2013, 10, pp. 253-282.
——, “The Archipelago and the Wheel: The Universal Jurisdiction and the International Criminal Court Regimes”, en MINOW, Martha, TRUE-FROST, Cora & WHITING, Alex, The First Global Prosecutor. Promises and Constraints, 2015.
——, “The Diplomacy of Universal Jurisdiction: The Political Branches and the Transnational Prosecution of International Crimes”, en American Journal of International Law, 2011, 105, Nº1, 01/2011, pp. 1-49.
——, “Universal jurisdiction as Janus-faced: The dual nature of the German international criminal code”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2013, 11, Nº 4, 10/2013, pp. 737-762.
——, “Universal Jurisdiction is Not Disappearing: The Shift from ‘Global Enforcer’ to ‘No Safe Haven’ Universal Jurisdiction”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2015, 13, Nº 2, 04/2015, pp. 245-256.
LUBAN, David, “A Theory of Crimes against Humanity”, en The Yale Journal of International Law, 2004, 29, Nº 1, pp. 85-167.
——, “After the Honeymoon. Reflections on the Current State of International Criminal Justice”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2013, 11, Nº 3, 07/2013, pp. 505-515.
LUNDVALL, Bengt-Åke, “The economics of knowledge and learning”, en CHRISTENSEN, Jesper Lindgaard & LUNDVALL, Bengt-Åke, Product innovation interactive learning and economic performance, Vol. 8, 2004.
MANDEL-ANTHONY, David, Conference on Times of Reckoning, Kline School of Law, Drexel University, Philadelphia, 12/10/2018.
MENNECKE, Martin, “The African Union and Universal Jurisdiction”, en JALLOH, Charles Chernor & BANTEKAS, Ilias, International Criminal Court and Africa, Oxford University Press, 2017, Oxford.
O’KEEFE, Roger, “Universal Jurisdiction: Clarifying the Basic Concept”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2004, 2, Nº 3, 09/2004, pp. 735-760.
Opinio Juris, “And So It Begins... Social Media Evidence In An ICC Arrest Warrant IRVING, Emma, 17/08/2017 URL http://opiniojuris.org/2017/08/17/and-so-it-begins-social-media-evidence-in-an-icc-arrest-warrant/ consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “Guest Post: the Zimbabwe Torture Docket Case”, 20/05/2014 URL http://opiniojuris.org/2014/05/20/guest-post-zimbabwe-torture-docket-case/ consultado 03/04/2021.
OSIEL, Mark, Mass atrocity, collective memory, and the law, Routledge, 1997, Nuevo Brunswick.
Parlamento de Sudáfrica, “Implementation of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Act”, Act Nº 27, 18/07/2002.
Procuración General de la Nación de Argentina, Resolución PGN 698/16, 20/03/2016.
Público, “‘Depende de la política española que se avance en la causa del franquismo’”, 23/07/2017 URL https://www.publico.es/politica/maria-servini-cubria-depende-politica-espanola-avance-causa-franquismo.html consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “Ciudadanos argentinos presentan la primera querella contra Israel por ‘genocidio’ en Gaza”, 06/09/2014 URL https://www.publico.es/internacional/ciudadanos-argentinos-presentan-primera-querella.html consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “La jueza argentina que investiga crímenes franquistas sigue sin recibir respuesta de España para interrogar a Martín Villa”, 18/10/2018 URL https://www.publico.es/politica/jueza-argentina-investiga-crimenes-franquistas-sigue-recibir-respuesta-espana-interrogar-martin-villa.html consultado 03/04/2021.
REEVES, Anthony, “Liability to International Prosecution: The Nature of Universal Jurisdiction”, en European Journal of International Law, 2017, 28, Nº 4, pp. 1047-1067.
Reino de España, Fiscalía del Estado de España, N/Ref.: S.T. 412/216.A, Madrid, 30/09/2016.
Reino de España, Fiscalía No. 7, Dictamen No. 24.375, 28/11/2018.
República Federal Alemana, Deutscher Bundestag, Drucksache 18/12533, 30/05/2017.
República Federal Alemana, Deutscher Bundestag, Völkerstrafgesetzbuch, Código de delitos contra el derecho internacional, 30/06/2002.
Reuters, “Argentine judge asks China arrests over Falun Gong” en Reuters, HENAO, Luis Andrés, 22/12/2009 URL https://www.reuters.com/article/us-argentina-china-falungong-idUSTRE5BM02B20091223 consultado 03/04/2021.
REYDAMS, Luc, “The Rise and Fall of universal Jurisdiction”, en SCHABAS, William A. & BERNAZ, Nadia, Routledge Handbook of International Criminal Law, Routledge, 2011, Londres.
——, “Universal criminal jurisdiction: the Belgian state of affairs”, en Criminal Law Forum, 2000, 11, Nº 2, pp. 183-216.
ROTH-ARRIAZA, Naomi, “Just a Bubble? Perspectives on the Enforcement of International Criminal Law by National Courts”, en Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2013, 11, Nº3, 07/2013, pp. 537-543.
SIKKINK, Kathryn, Justice cascade: How human rights prosecutions are changing world politics, W. W. Norton & Company, 2011, New York.
SNYDER, Jack & VINJAMURI, Leslie, “Trials and Errors”, en International Security, 2003/2004, 28, Nº 3, pp. 5-44.
Spiegel Online, “Deutschland jagt Assads Folterknecht”, 08/06/2018 URL https://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/syrien-deutschland-jagt-baschar-al-assads-folterknecht-per-haftbefehl-a-1211888.html consultado 03/04/2021.
Statut des Chambres africaines extraordinaires au sein des juridictions sénégalaises pour la poursuite des crimes internationaux commis au Tchad durant la période du 7 juin 1982 au 1er décembre 1990, 31/01/2012, Adís Abeba.
Tages Anzeiger, “Schweizer Justiz ermittelt wegen Kriegsverbrechen in Syrien”, 02/10/2016 URL https://www.tagesanzeiger.ch/schweiz/standard/schweizer-justiz-ermittelt-wegen-kriegsverbrechen-in-syrien/story/21007826 consultado 03/04/2021.
TEITEL, Ruti, Transitional Justice, Oxford University Press, 2000, Nueva York.
The Guardian, “Israeli minister Tzipi Livni given diplomatic immunity for UK visit”, 13/05/2014 URL https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/13/israel-tzipi-livni-diplomatic-immunity-uk consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “Judge to investigate Franco-era crimes against Spanish women”, 26/10/2018 URL https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/26/judge-investigate-franco-era-crimes-against-spanish-women-sexual-assault-forced-abortion-child-theft#:~:text=Judge%20Mar%C3%ADa%20Servini%20de%20Cubr%C3%ADa,the%20principle%20of%20universal%20jurisdiction consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “UK to review war crimes warrants after Tzipi Livni arrest row”, 15/12/2009 URL https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/dec/15/israel-tzipi-livni-arrest-warrant consultado 03/04/2021.
The New York Times, “9 Syrian Officials Are Accused of Torture in Spanish Court”, 02/02/2017 URL https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/02/world/europe/spain-syria-torture-case.html consultado 03/04/2021.
——, “Argentine Prosecutors Consider Charges Against Saudi Crown Prince Ahead of G-20”, 26/11/2018 URL https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/26/world/americas/argentina-crown-prince-mohammed-saudi-arabia.html consultado 03/04/2021.
The Washington Post, “Here’s how German courts are planning to prosecute Syrian war crimes”, 04/04/2017 URL https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/democracy-post/wp/2017/04/04/heres-how-german-courts-are-planning-to-prosecute-syrian-war-crimes/ consultado 03/04/2021.
Tribunal Supremo de España, Sala de lo penal, “Caso Scilingo”, 01/10/2007.
VAN SCHAAK, Beth & PEROVIC, Zarko, “The Prevalence of ‘Present-In’ Jurisdiction”, en Sociedad Estadounidense de Derecho Internacional, Proceedings of the 107th Annual Meeting, 2013.
VIERUCCI, Luisa, “The first steps of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia”, en European Journal of International Law, 1995, 6, Nº 1, 02/1995, pp. 134-143.
WERLE, Gerhard, Africa and the International Criminal Court, Asser Press, 2014, Berlín.
Wired, “The Hague Convicts a Tomb-Destroying Extremist with Smart Design”, 25/08/2016 URL https://www.wired.com/2016/08/hague-convicts-tomb-destroying-terrorist-smart-design/ consultado 03/04/2021.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Revista Lecciones y Ensayos
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
